Why Can't We Do Anything About Joe Manchin?
Joe Manchin's political stance has frequently been a source of frustration, especially for those on either side of the aisle. Whether you are a conservative or a liberal, Manchin's ability to bridge the gap and often align with his Republican peers has left many questioning why more can't be done to spark change. Reflecting on Manchin's career and his impact on American politics, this analysis aims to provide a nuanced understanding of the situation.
Joe Manchin: A Luminous Figure in American Politics
Manchin has a long-standing political career that spans 40 years. He has always been affiliated with the Democratic party, but his approach has been notably centrist rather than liberal. This unique positioning makes him a crucial figure in the Senate, often acting as a moderating influence. For conservatives, Manchin's willingness to vote for some legislation that aligns with Republican priorities offers a rare opportunity for bipartisan progress. Conversely, liberals appreciate that he would likely be replaced by someone more aligned with the far-right, such as Patrick Morrissey, who is a staunch conservative.
Challenges and Successes
Despite his sometimes bottlenecking effect, Manchin's support has been instrumental in passing significant legislation. Even in a 50-50 Senate, Democrats have managed to achieve substantial gains. Notable bills that have passed include two budget reconciliation bills, an infrastructure bill, a gun control bill, and the CHIPS Act. Additionally, Joe Biden successfully confirmed 84 judges, including Justice Jackson, a milestone that might not have been possible without Manchin's support.
Republican Control and Its Impact
The alternative scenario involving Manchin's potential replacement by a MAGA Republican who is unlikely to vote for any legislation supported by the Democrats, coupled with a Republican-controlled Senate, paints a bleak picture for progressive policies. In this hypothetical, Democrats would struggle to achieve much. However, Manchin's consistent voting with Democrats in the 117th Congress (about 90% of the time) has enabled them to accomplish a significant amount of their agenda.
Conclusion
While the political landscape often feels stagnant due to the presence of Joe Manchin, his influence has been far from detrimental. In a divided Senate, his ability to build bridges and find common ground has been particularly crucial. For both conservatives and liberals, Manchin's position highlights the delicate balance needed in a politically charged environment. His mandate in West Virginia, representing a diverse constituency, has made him a necessary part of the Democratic coalition, ensuring that even when compromises are necessary, legislation can still be passed.