Understanding Common Rule Violations of Wikipedia Deletions
Wikipedia, the world’s largest, collaborative, and peer-produced online encyclopedia, operates on a set of strict guidelines designed to maintain the accuracy, reliability, and quality of its content. However, not all contributions meet these standards, leading to potential deletions. In this article, we explore the most common rule violations that result in the deletion of Wikipedia entries, primarily through the actions of volunteer administrators.
1. Lack of Notability: Why Your Game Isn't Special Enough
Perhaps the most frequent reason for the deletion of a Wikipedia entry is a lack of notability. While the concept of notability might seem subjective, it ensures that only topics that are relevant and sufficiently referenced in reputable sources are included. For instance, if someone says, "This is a game me and my buds made up and we have a YouTube up explaining it that’s gotten thousands of views!," this claim alone is not enough to establish notability.
Example
Evidence Needed for Notability: "This is a game that has gained.
thousands of players and has been featured in major gaming magazines and websites. The rules have been documented in a publication by an educational institution."
It's important to recognize that personal anecdotes and isolated instances of popularity do not satisfy the notability requirement. Volunteer administrators rely on verifiable sources and established criteria to make deletion decisions.
2. WP:G5: Deletion for Block-Evading Users
The WP:G5 guideline addresses the issue of users who circumvent blocking measures to continue contributing to Wikipedia. This rule was implemented to counter the frustration of both block-evading users and those who may inadvertently block contributors due to their online behavior.
Why WP:G5?
Skepticism and Stress:** The block appeal process can be mentally and emotionally taxing, requiring contributors to plead and network with administrators before being allowed to continue editing.
Resource Allocation:** The block evasion problem diverts resources from areas where the encyclopedia could benefit most, as administrators and other users have to address these issues instead of enhancing the content.
The core principle of WP:G5 is that the quality of the content is what matters, not the process or the method used to evade restrictions. This approach aims to create a more inclusive and productive environment for all contributors.
3. Copyright Violations: Intellectual Property on Wikipedia
A significant concern in the realm of Wikipedia contributions is the proper attribution and handling of copyrighted material. Just because content is available on the internet does not mean it is free for use on Wikipedia. Users must ensure that all content is either openly licensed or used with proper attribution and permissions.
Example
Incorrect Usage: Copying and pasting content from a commercial website without permission or licensing.
Wikipedia has strict policies against plagiarism and copyright infringement. Any content that is not in the public domain or lacks proper licensing must be excluded.
4. Overly Promotional Content: NPOV and Keeps Wiki Neutral
A common notability issue on Wikipedia is the submission of articles that are overly promotional or biased. Wikipedia maintains a strict neutral point of view (NPOV). The purpose of the encyclopedia is to present information in a balanced and impartial manner, free from promotional or biased content.
Example
Incorrect: "XYZ Corporation's financial success is unparalleled and has contributed greatly to its community."
Correct: "XYZ Corporation has been successful financially and has had a positive impact on its community, though some critics point to other companies with comparable growth."
Every article should present a fair and balanced view, considering anecdotal evidence and official reports, rather than promotional statements.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the deletion of Wikipedia entries due to common rule violations highlights the necessity of adhering to Wikipedia's guidelines. Whether it's establishing notability, respecting copyright, maintaining a neutral point of view, or avoiding block evasion, each contributor plays a crucial role in maintaining the integrity and reliability of the encyclopedia. Understanding these guidelines and adhering to them can significantly enhance the value and impact of one's contributions to Wikipedia.