The Illusion of Repatriated Black Money: Debunking the Swiss Bank Hoax and the Conundrum of Political Financing
Recent claims about returning unaccounted money held in Swiss bank accounts have sparked a heated debate in India. This article aims to dissect the veracity of such claims and explore the implications of political financing through electoral bonds. We will also examine the potential for bringing black money back into the country and how it might benefit Indian citizens.
The Mirage: Accessing Foreign Accounts in India
A simple exercise suggests the daunting reality of accessing foreign accounts in India. Try asking your close relative's bank about the balance of their account. Most banks would not divulge this information, even upon claiming to be a relative. This accessibility issue highlights the complexity of bringing foreign-held black money back to India.
However, recent scandals and political rhetoric have pushed the topic into the limelight. For instance, when a politician suggested these funds could be accessed, it turned out they had moved the money to a 'Foreign Event Carnivals Unlisted' (FECU) account. The funds were used to create massive roadshows to project the government's accomplishments.
The Political Gambit: Electoral Bonds and Swiss Bank Lists
Back in 2015, Swiss banks released a list of 1,195 Indians holding unaccounted funds amounting to around Rs. 25,000 crores. Following this revelation, a political party seized the opportunity to introduce the electoral bond scheme in 2016 and 2017. The amendment aimed to provide a mechanism to launder black money and funnel it into political coffers.
The current electoral bond scheme was introduced through amendments to four legislations: the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act (FCRA), the Representation of the People Act (RoPA), the Income Tax Act, and the Companies Act. This move significantly changed the political landscape by allowing shell companies to make political contributions, raising concerns about the legitimacy of such funding.
Electoral Funding through Electoral Bonds
Between 2016-17 and 2021-22, national and regional parties received a total of Rs. 9,188.35 crore through electoral bonds. Notably, national parties experienced a significant increase in donations, up by 743% between 2017-18 and 2021-22, underscoring the growing reliance on such funding mechanisms.
Regional parties also witnessed a substantial proportion of their donations coming from electoral bonds, indicating that black money is permeating political financing across the board. The removal of the 7.5% net average profit requirement under the Companies Act 2013 has further raised concerns about the potential influx of black money through unscrupulous means.
The Reality Check: A Dream or a Dilemma?
Despite the rhetoric, the Indian government and its allies have made little effort to repatriate the funds held in Swiss banks. Indian citizens should be wary of optimistic claims about bringing back black money. The likelihood of such funds benefiting the populace is minimal, given the vested interests of those in power. Politicians and bureaucrats have shown little inclination to use these funds to address genuine developmental needs.
The truth is that black money in political financing undermines democratic processes and hampers economic reforms. Without meaningful action to curb the flow of unaccounted funds, the country risks continuing to suffer from corruption and economic mismanagement.
Conclusion: The prospect of bringing back black money from Swiss banks is a mirage. Instead of dreaming of repatriation, citizens should focus on holding politicians accountable and demanding transparency in political funding. Until genuine steps are taken to stop the inflow of black money, the promises of a brighter future remain untouchable.
References: