Stimulus Money for Illegal Aliens: Debunking Myths and Analyzing Policy Perspectives
The Current Controversy: Recently, there has been a flurry of debate around the possibility of using stimulus money to aid illegal aliens. While no individual or legislative body has formally proposed this, the discussion has brought to light the contributions made by undocumented workers to various government services and the complexities of immigration policy.
Senator AOC's Proposal
One of the most discussed pieces of this debate is U.S. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC)'s stance. AOC has argued for distributing stimulus money to all citizens, including illegal aliens, based on their contributions to the country.
According to a 2017 report from the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, undocumented immigrants paid a significant amount in taxes in 2014. Specifically, they contributed approximately $11.7 billion in state and local taxes, which include $7 billion in sales taxes and excise taxes. Additionally, they paid about $1.1 billion in state income taxes and $3.6 billion in property taxes. These taxes fund essential services like highway repairs, state courts, police, and firefighters, as well as public schools and city services.
Moreover, these individuals contribute an estimated $13 billion in federal taxes each year, primarily through payroll taxes. Since they do not have Social Security numbers, they cannot claim these contributions when they retire, nor can they access the benefits they have helped to fund.
Republican Perspectives
On the opposite end of the spectrum, some Republican lawmakers have suggested that the stimulus package should benefit corporations and wealthy individuals rather than undocumented immigrants or low-income citizens. For instance, a proposal was made to fund the yacht and limousine expenses of Wall Street tycoons.
However, a more accurate example has come to light, which involves the Leave No Taxpayer Behind Act introduced by U.S. Congressman Lou Correa. This legislation aims to include immigrants, documented and undocumented, in the coronavirus relief response, specifically stating that it’s for all taxpayers. The comments accompanying this bill suggest that it is indeed intended for undocumented immigrants who pay taxes.
Legislative Context
No formal proposal has been made at the federal level to give stimulus money directly to illegal aliens. However, the debate has sparked discussions about the contribution of undocumented workers and the potential for more inclusive policies.
It's important to note that while these discussions highlight the contributions of undocumented immigrants, they also highlight the complexities surrounding tax contributions and immigration policies.
Conclusion
Currently, no major legislative body has formally proposed giving stimulus money directly to illegal aliens. Yet, the conversation around tax contributions and immigration highlights significant issues that need addressing. A more inclusive approach to tax distribution could ensure that all taxpayers, regardless of legal status, see the benefits of the government's relief efforts.
Key Takeaways
The debate around stimulus money for illegal aliens reflects the significant contributions of undocumented immigrants to government services. Legislation such as the Leave No Taxpayer Behind Act seeks to include all taxpayers, including undocumented immigrants, in relief efforts. The contributions of undocumented workers through taxes are substantial, yet they do not reap the benefits of these contributions in retirement or through government services.Keywords: stimulus money, illegal aliens, tax contributions