Is It Wrong to Want to Return a Cat You Don't Bond With?

Adopting a cat is a big responsibility that involves commitment, love, and patience. However, every story is unique, and sometimes, despite our best efforts, the bond between a person and their feline companion may not form. This article aims to explore whether it's acceptable or even necessary to consider returning a cat that you don't feel connected with.

The Importance of Bonding

Many people believe that bonding with a cat is crucial. It takes time for a cat to feel comfortable and trust their new human family. In my experience, I've adopted several cats, and each has required a different approach to build this trust. For instance, one of my earlier adoptees, Kip, was wary and would only come out of his hiding spot to eat and use his litter box. Through consistent interaction, patience, and gentle encouragement, Kip eventually warmed up to me and our bond grew stronger until he passed away at the ripe old age of 14.

It's important to recognize that not all cats will bond in the same way or within the same timeframe. Some require more time, understanding, and patience. However, at the same time, it's equally crucial not to force the issue if a bond seems impossible. Every cat is a unique individual with their own personality and needs.

Ethical Considerations in Cat Adoption

While it’s natural to feel a strong bond with a cat once they've integrated into your life, it's also important to consider what might happen if you feel emotionally wounded or begin to resent the cat. Resentment can lead to a toxic relationship that may harm the cat's well-being. It's essential to remember that cats are social beings who can feel stress and anxiety, just like humans do. Their behavior and emotions can be affected by changes in their environment and the attitudes of their caretakers.

Likewise, you might be concerned that if you return the cat, you might not feel capable of adopting another one. I strongly advise against making major decisions under emotional distress. Instead, take the time to process your feelings and regain your emotional balance. This way, you can make a rational decision that aligns with your best interests and the cat's well-being.

Taking the Cat Back and Finding a New Home

Returning a cat to a rescue or another adoptive family can sometimes be the best outcome. By doing so, you are giving the cat another chance to find a new home where they might be better suited. You can ensure that the new home is a more experienced or better-equipped environment to care for the cat. This might provide the cat with a better opportunity for a happy life.

Your experience with the cat can also be valuable; you've learned what the cat needs, and this knowledge can be shared with the rescue or new adoptive family. They can use this information to create the best possible environment for the cat. It's a responsible decision that ensures the cat's subsequent well-being.

Reflection and Future Considerations

The decision to return a cat should not be made hastily. Instead, take the time to reflect on why you're considering this option. Consider the emotional impact on both of you and whether returning the cat could lead to a more harmonious future for both of you. If you decide to return the cat, please do so in a way that minimizes any distress they might experience and gives them the best possible chance of finding a loving home.

If you conclude that you don't want to return the cat, there are other steps you can take. Research how cats work and talk to experienced cat owners. By doing so, you can enhance your understanding and improve the chances of forming a strong bond with your feline companion. Remember, the decision to adopt a cat is a long-term commitment that requires patience, love, and dedication.