Is Donald Trump a Big Government Conservative?
The question of whether Donald Trump can be classified as a big government conservative has been a topic of much debate among political analysts and commentators. Views on this matter are split, reflecting a wide range of perspectives and interpretations. Let's explore these differing viewpoints in detail.
No. He Is Cutting Regulations and Bureaucracy
One argument against labeling Trump as a big government conservative is his focus on slashing regulations and reducing government oversight. This approach has been a central theme of his administration, driven by the belief that cumbersome regulations hinder economic growth and innovation.
Trump's efforts at deregulation began with his inaugural address, where he pledged to eliminate bureaucratic red tape. This push towards deregulation has been a hallmark of his tenure, with advocates arguing that it has contributed to a robust economic environment. While his economic policies have had their successes and failures, the argument that he is not a big government conservative centers on these efforts to reduce the burden on businesses and the economy.
No. He Is Not Filling Key Posts
Another argument that Trump is not a big government conservative is the lack of filling his posts as required by law. As a constitutional and legal requirement, Trump has not filled a significant portion of these positions, which is seen as a counterpoint to his claim of increasing government size.
This demonstrates a difference from traditional big government conservatives who often advocate for a large and active government structure. Trump's failure to fill these posts actually suggests a diminished approach to government expansion, contrary to the notion of a big government agenda.
Donald Trump’s Moderation and Rightward Shift
Donald Trump’s instincts are often described as those of a moderate conservative, but his reactions to the abusive tactics of his opponents have pushed him to the right. This has resulted in policies that some argue go beyond what might be expected of a traditional conservative, but not necessarily those of a big government conservative.
Trumponomics, as some have called his economic policies, have a focus on deregulation and small government. For example, his push for the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act in 2017, which significantly reduced corporate tax rates, aligns more with a lean government approach rather than a big government one. Trump has not proposed the creation of any substantial new departments, with the exception of the Space Force, which is more about reorganizing existing assets rather than expanding government.
No! He Is a BIG TRUMP Conservative
Conversely, some argue that Trump represents a unique conservative philosophy that prioritizes his control over the government and the public. This perspective sees Trump as a figure who seeks to dominate both the political establishment and the public discourse, shaping policies to his will rather than adhering to traditional conservative principles.
Trump's administration has been marked by various controversies, including the shutdown of the economy due to health care regulations or the cancellation of programs that he deemed unworthy. This suggests a more autocratic and personalized approach to governance, which is at odds with the idea of a big government structure.
No! He Is Not a Conservative
A significant counterpoint is that Trump is perceived as a narcissist and a pathological liar, with a significant disconnect from reality. His political beliefs and policies are often seen as a means to engage his base and maintain a cult of personality, rather than a genuine commitment to conservative values.
Before entering politics, Trump expressed liberal views on many issues, indicating a lack of genuine conservative convictions. His current behavior is more seen as a strategic move to resonate with and mobilize his supporters, rather than a reflection of true conservative principles.
Conclusion
The debate over whether Donald Trump is a big government conservative is complex and multifaceted. While his focus on deregulation and reduction of government oversight aligns with smaller government principles, his failure to fill key posts and his tendency towards autocratic governance suggest a more nuanced approach. Whether he is a truly big government conservative is open to interpretation and depends on one's perspective on his policies and actions.